Tuesday, 12 April 2011

Widespread genetic screening risks creating 'inferior' citizens


Back in 1995, my 14-year-old self was sitting on the dusty floor of my all-girls’ school hall listening to a morning assembly. With the aim of promoting public speaking, each class had to give one annual school assembly speech on a topic of their choosing. That morning it was the turn of five 11-year-olds who had decided to tackle a topic beyond their years: abortion. At 8.50am on one nondescript Spring morning my whole life was pronounced worthless as they declared that mothers carrying foetuses with Cystic Fibrosis (CF) would understandably want a termination. As a CF sufferer myself, I laughed aloud at the suggestion.  Even as the illness has slowly ruined my lungs over the years, my life is still definitely one that is worth living.

Yet a report out this week by the Human Genetics Commission reminded me of those thoughtless 11-year-olds. Its pronouncement that they see “no specific social, ethical or legal principles" against offering nationwide preconception screening of genetic conditions seemed, at best, ill thought through.

In its report, ‘Increasing options, informing choice’, the Commission recommends that any person should be eligible for tests to show whether they are a carrier of genetic abnormalities that could result in their child being born with illnesses such as CF or Sickle Cell Anemia. Currently such tests are limited to people who already know there is a family risk of such illnesses.

The report believes that by widening out pre-screening to every potential parent in the UK people “can make informed choices about the reproductive options available to them.” Yet these choices seem to be very limited: remain childless, have an abortion, or endure lengthy, and possibly futile, IVF treatment.

It is possible to carry out an antenatal test called Chorionic villus sampling to see whether a foetus has CF, so that the family can choose to abort the pregnancy before birth.  Cystic Fibrosis is a tough illness and it cuts life expectancy by at least 50%. Yet people with CF can live a relatively normal life for long periods of time. We have active childhoods, careers of our choosing and a life lived independently. I have a great life full of amazing friends. I’ve had a brilliant education, a good career, and even now when my health is really quite bad I live with an amazing man who I’m marrying in two months’ time. Is this a life that would have been better aborted?

Moreover, it is easy to imagine a scenario where a childless couple in their fifties may look back on multiple abortions, undergone due to fear of bringing up a child with CF, and wonder if it wouldn’t have been better to have experienced parenthood with all the hardships and happiness it would have brought with it. Perhaps the knowledge that pre-screening brings may be as painful as the very grief it was aimed at avoiding.

If both parents are a carrier of the defective CF gene, IVF is the only way to be sure of not conceiving a child with CF. In a process called Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) each embryo is screened to ensure it is genetically ‘normal’ before implantation in the womb: there is at best a 30% success rate. But with NHS funding currently under strain, IVF is being severely limited across the country. In the last three years, nearly one in five Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) have cut IVF funding, with nine areas refusing funding altogether. Even fewer PCTs are prepared to pay for PGD in comparison with traditional IVF procedures and privately the procedure costs £3,000 per attempt.

It would be a nightmare scenario if CF became a ‘poor’ person’s illness, only prevalent in parts of society that cannot afford private PGD sessions. What implications will this have into research for a cure, or for NHS and welfare provisions for people with such illnesses?

It is unsurprising that Dr David King, director of Human Genetics Alert, said that if the report recommendations were put into action "it will inevitably lead to young people [diagnosed as carriers] being stigmatised and becoming unmarriageable, and disabled people will feel even more threatened."

For me the recommendations of the Human Genetics Commission imply that a life with CF, or Sickle Cell, or any other serious genetic illness, is a life not worth living. Ultimately no one chooses to have CF but isn’t that different to taking active steps to avoid having a child with CF? The Commission seems ignorant of the fact that people with severe illnesses have a lot to give, both to the people who love them and the society of which they are a part.

Everyone has hardships in their life, and CF is mine, but living with it has given me strength as well as pain. Rather than encouraging people to consider children with genetic illnesses as inferior, it should be recognised that our society is in fact strengthened when it comprises a diverse range of people with their own unique way of living their life as best they can.

Thursday, 17 March 2011

Are Lansley's days well and truly numbered?

I would love to be a fly on the wall in the Government's health department at the moment as the department's policies have recently been attacked from all directions. Health charities, coalition MPs and nationwide GPs have very publicly criticised different aspects of the Government's health policies and I would think that Andrew Lansley, the Secretary of State for Health, will probably spend the upcoming weekend contemplating how much longer he can cling to his post.

To give you some background, Lansley was Shadow secretary for health for ten years before the Tories formed a Government last year. It seems that spending such a long time in a single role in opposition has left Lansley with incredibly ambitious ideas that seem one step removed from the practical reality of a country with a shaky economy. Indeed so protective has Lansley been of his department, rumours have been circulating that it has isolated itself from all other Government offices. A BBC World at One report earlier this year revealed that Cameron has increased the number of policy advisors at Number 10 so he could get a better understanding of the health policy that Lansley has been guarding behind closed doors.

Back in 2001, Britain was starting a decade of cheap credit, low cost of living and continuous growth. As the decade progressed, Lansley could be forgiven for thinking our country was stable enough to allow for the biggest reorganisation of the NHS since its inception in 1948. However, so keen is Lansley to unleash plans that were so long in the making, he seems unwilling to recognise that the country is very different to what he had envisioned. Lansley's NHS reorganisation is meant to cost anywhere between £1.4 and £3 billion pounds - and with the UK supporting a massive deficit it is no wonder the nation is wondering if we can afford these changes right now. Moreover the meltdown of the UK banks has left our country more political. Whereas in the good years we might have been too busy buying expensive clothes on credit and binge drinking away our weekends to criticise our politicians, in our current sober times more and more British people are vocally questioning Government policies.

Yet despite this climate, Lansley announced a "revolution" of our NHS when he released his department's NHS white paper last July. As doctors, health charities, journalists, patients and opposition MPs have begun to understand the implications of this white paper, the dissent has slowly risen. Even Cameron's direct media intervention earlier this year to help 'sell' the Government's NHS white paper has done little to assuage mounting criticism. Cameron may now be calling the NHS changes an "evolution" instead of a "revolution" but many still believe his NHS proposals are leading us down the road of privatisation.

And so to this week. The British Medical Association called an emergency meeting, the first for 17 years, in which GPs voted in favour of the motion that Lansley entirely withdraw the Health bill currently going through parliament and halt reorganisation plans. In separate news, on Monday six health groups refused to sign up to the Government's 'responsibility deal' on alcohol saying that the voluntary measures do not ask enough of the drinks industry. Don Shenker, Chief executive of Alcohol Concern, said that the Government's public health policy's "first priority is to side with big business and protect profits". Finally, Lib Dem activists have voted overwhelmingly to reject the Coalition's NHS reforms as they believe they are unjustified and will be highly damaging.

So where to now? My feeling is that David Cameron will fall back on his old PR background and consider that the way to win round voters is to alter the presentation of NHS reforms. And perhaps he will conclude that Andrew 'Revolution' Lansley is now too toxic a figure to be spearheading such divisive changes. Such a move would suit Clegg as well who, after the fallout of tuition fees, has to show his party that he has listened to their doubts. So I think Lansley's days are numbered and if rumours on Twitter are to be believed a possible replacement might be Grant Shapps, currently the minister for housing and local Government.

But Clegg and Cameron should be warned. A change of Minister might win them some breathing space but they will still have a case to answer as to where the electoral mandate is for such reforms. Neither the Tory or Lib Dem manifestos mentioned such sweeping changes to the NHS, and the Coalition document was also silent on the issue. Lansley may well be forced to fall on his sword but that sword is razor sharp and capable of taking many more victims.

Tuesday, 8 March 2011

How CF and heart surgery reveal a gap in GP commissioning

As GPs across the country grapple with how best to commission care for their users, the King's Fund raised serious concern last week about how groups of GP consortia can be expected to understand the complexities of our nationwide hospital provision.

In a report out earlier this month called Reconfiguring Hospital Services, the King's Fund says that sorting out how to improve the quality of hospital care may well result in closing some hospitals or consolidating what services each hospital offers. They are concerned that the impending abolishment of strategic health authorities, along with Primary Care Trusts, means that there will be no umbrella view of hospital services and stress that, in their opinion, "Market forces alone are unlikely to result in improvements in quality of care for patients in many hospitals, and could result in deterioration in some cases".

A classic case of such complexities is the current Government review of Specialist services which is currently looking into which hospitals in the UK will provide congenital heart surgery for children. It is recommending that such procedures are carried out in just six or seven hospitals in the future which means that of the four current London providers only two will remain.

The reasons for consolidating care aren't just concerned with funding. There is evidence to suggest that the more surgery a surgeon performs the better he becomes at it and, in addition, the larger the hospital the better the survival rates. This isn't rocket science: one of my first ever posts discussed a surgeon's success in terms of Malcolm Gladwell's theory that it takes 10,000 hours of practice to become great at something.

But while there may be a case for reducing such nationwide congenital surgery centres from 11 to 6 or 7, there are unexpected consequences for those patients who don't have congenital heart conditions but also receive treatment at the hospitals under scrutiny.

The Government's review currently favours maintaining congenital heart surgery at Great Ormond Street Hospital and Evelina Children's hospital, which means Brompton Hospital in London would lose its ability to offer this treatment. I was surprised to hear that the Cystic Fibrosis Trust is campaigning against the Brompton hospital losing its congenital heart care. I'm a CF patient at Brompton and I didn't see the connection.

But the CF Trust is worried that if Brompton loses its ability to provide congenital heart care then it will not have the patient base to justify it having a children's intensive care unit and anaesthesia service. Which means that the care available for paedeatric CF patients will be inadequate. This in turn places additional stress on the other three London hospitals that look after CF patients as they would need to find clinic space and bed space for over 300 additional patients that are currently looked after by Brompton.

And for me, an adult CF patient, it makes me worry that there will be a knock-on effect on the care I receive at Brompton as there would no longer be a future patient base of CF children that would grow up to need an adult CF service. Brompton provides world-class care for Cystic Fibrosis patients so surely it can't be intentional that this service is now under threat?

This does all sound complicated, but it is this detailed understanding of the demands on individual hospitals and the ability to foresee the effects of curtailing certain patient services that the Government must retain. The concern is whether GP consortia will be able to get to grips with the reforms that hospitals will require without the quality of care being affected for all the many patient types that use each hospital.

The King's Fund believes that GP consortia will not have the experience or size to implement major service improvements in hospitals and is urging that the Government's new NHS Commissioning Board be given greater powers to strategically plan hospital services. It argues that without these powers the system will gravitate to a 'market forces' model and this will not provide any improvement in the quality of care patients receive. And remember, the Government promises that a key aim behind its proposed overhaul of the NHS is to improve care - it is clear to me that to do this the Government must start looking at the limitations of GP commissioning as well at the advantages.

Wednesday, 23 February 2011

NHS reforms: Patient choice may have positive side-effects

Patient choice is a key element behind Lansley's reforms. The idea is that choice will help health services will improve without the need for central management. Patients will "vote with their feet" and only use good services, leaving those NHS providers who aren't good at what they do to either improve or close down.

I'm not too sure what I'd feel if I was one of the poor patients who had to suffer bad treatment before the rest of us all cottoned on and ran screaming from the hospital, but that aside, this idea of patient choice may actual have the knock-on effect of being beneficial for our health.

To help manage my Cystic Fibrosis, I constantly self-monitor my health. Off by heart I know my hospital number, weight to 0.1 of a kg, height, average pulse rate, average oxygen saturation in my blood, and all my lung function stats. I actually know when I'm more ill than my lung function stats would suggest and I get to have a big say in what treatment I have. For example, my hospital constantly tell me to put on weight so I've just asked them to send me a clinical study of the long-term health benefits for CF patients if they are over a BMI of 19.

It may seem weird that I like to know the medical facts and figures behind everything, but the more I understand the importance of my medicine the more likely I am to make the extra effort to take it all - and believe me, there is a lot to take.

So it made me realise that the idea of informed choice behind the NHS reforms might actually improve our individual health as well as the performance of health providers. If we feel actively involved in our own treatment we may be more likely to take our drugs and take note of all the other bits and pieces we can all do to help our treatment work more quickly: eat better, exercise more and sleep regularly.

Moreover, if we feel like we are in control of our treatment it might make us feel more positive about coping while ill and motivate us to get better as soon as possible.

Working out how to get us to self-manage our health better is definitely a shift that the whole of society needs to make. With obesity levels and alcohol abuse on the rise, the whole country needs to recognise that good health starts with us. Any NHS system that advocates public health awareness but simultaneously fails to provide a choice in treatment of specific health-problems is sending out mixed messages to us all.

Patient choice may not prove effective at deciding which companies should provide our NHS care but the drive to provide greater information and choice to patients could be an interesting way to get us to think again about our own responsibility towards our individual health.

Wednesday, 2 February 2011

Time to rethink the approach to NHS reforms

The first debate of the NHS reforms took place on Monday, and the second reading of the bill was passed with 321 MPs voting for and 235 voting against. It followed six hours of debating.

But while MPs are battling each other in the House of Commons, they are also trying to win over the public to their plans. So wide-reaching are the reforms, it has taken a while for health journalists to fully realise the implications, let alone the general public who have very little understanding of the NHS machinations at work behind their GP surgery.

This week has been full of statistics and surveys aimed at influencing the direction of the debate. While the reforms are focused on giving power to the GPs over the way NHS money is spent, it is the MPs who will decide whether the reforms are happening. So GPs, powerless in the face of empowerment, are using the media to bang on the doors of the Commons. A snapshot survey of the Royal College of General Practitioners, found that of 1,800 responses, 70% disagreed or strongly disagreed that patient outcomes would improve by opening up the NHS to private companies. 50% also felt GP commissioning would not give more power to patients.

And the MPs themselves have resorted to throwing statistics at the press in the hope of making their opinion the dominant story in the papers. Shadow health secretary John Healey claimed that 3 out of every 4 GPs disagreed that NHS reforms would improve patient changes. (The excellent blog Factcheck questioned the veracity of this stat though).

The Tories have hit back at Labour claiming these reforms were begun in part by Blair's Government. I'm currently reading Andrew Rawnsley's brilliant book 'End of the Party' about the last two terms of the Labour Government. He continually highlights Blair's frustration at being unable to make great public service reforms. In a 2002 interview with Rawnsley, Blair said: "We will not maintain public services and the welfare state unless we radically recast them" (pg76). He wanted to introduce choice to the users of the NHS and diversity of providers, hoping the third sector and private companies would tender for contracts. His reforms were watered down due to party opposition, but it is clear that parts of New Labour were of the same mind as the Tories now are.

So the questions is, why can't we all have a sensible conversation about it?

If the parties are both thinking the same thing - that the NHS must change before it starts to fall-apart - then perhaps an honest conversation with the British public is required. In which the case for change is explained and a realistic time-frame is established for such measures. Perhaps the first step is to start on the path to GP commissioning, but in a more balanced, state-managed way rather then the piecemeal free-for-all that is currently being considered. Once commissioning is up and running then the next step might be to consider what benefit, if any, private companies can bring to the NHS.

In contrast, it is clear to me that the current state of affairs in which GPs are fighting to be heard and the public haven't even been asked their opinion will just result in chaos. The BMA today even said a strike over NHS reforms is a possibility.

As plans currently stand reforms could result in a wildly variant health-service - with some GPs succeeding with commissioning while others fail, and private companies taking advantage of the mess to take over services that undermine the viability of NHS hospitals.

The first step of reforms must be to accept that the NHS, which has been developing for 60 years, cannot be recast in just 60 months. And if reforms cannot be implemented before a general election, and a possible change-over of power, perhaps the fate of much-loved British institution is deserving of the parties to come together and work towards strong, effective and safe reforms for the NHS, which override party politics.

MPs that spend less time fighting each other could then spend more time listening to the opinion of those affected: medics, nurses and us, the service user.

Wednesday, 26 January 2011

Waiting-list Watch - part 1

In June 2010 health secretary Andrew Lansley scrapped NHS waiting list targets. He argued they created too much paper work and he wanted the NHS measured on "patient outcomes' instead of arbitrary targets. Unsurprisingly with the targets gone, waiting lists are now creeping up. Lansley is wrong to think patients will only judge the NHS on outcomes, they will judge it on the whole process from start to finish. How long you wait to see a doctor, receive a diagnosis and start treatment are intrinsic to what patients think about the NHS.

Trade magazine, Pulse, announced today that waiting lists have increased, on average, by a quarter already. 
For example:
  • The proportion of admitted patients who did not receive treatment within 18 weeks has risen by a fifth – from 6.7% to 8% – with 23,826 missing out.
  • Click here to find out more!The number of people waiting more than the previous target of six weeks for diagnostic tests rose by more than 90% compared with the same period last year.
In short, ill patients are being told to wait longer to receive treatment or to even know what is wrong with them.

All statistics are based on the Department of Health data. I'll continue to blog on waiting time targets, as it is my guess they will continue to rise and rise as the NHS struggles to make £20 billion of efficiency savings by 2014 with just a 0.1% annual increase to their budget in the same period.

Lansley may want to remember that NHS patients are also voters. His decision to scrap targets, which at the time received little coverage, may well come back to haunt him in four years time.

Tuesday, 25 January 2011

Introducing 'Where's the Benefit?' blog

I've just started contributing to a blog which is focused on highlighting cuts and changes to disabled benefits. Here is a link to my first post.

Going forward, I'll post most of my benefit related blogs on Where's the Benefit? and refocus this blog on all issues to do with the NHS, whether that be treatment, funding, reforms of personal experiences.