Wednesday, 27 June 2012

Government disability strategy delayed - reasons unknown?

The Government recently confirmed a delay in publishing its disability strategy. Originally due to be published in the Spring, the Office for Disability Issues has now announced that the strategy will be released 'later this year' - and have refused to give an explanation for the delay. But I could make a good guess.

In its consultation document, asking disabled people to contribute ideas to its final strategy, the Government said it was "committed to enabling disabled people to fulfil their potential and have the opportunity to play a full role in their community." However I've written before that this commitment is completely at odds with the reality of the impact of cuts on the ground. Disabled people have been hit hard by cuts and changes to Employment support allowance, housing benefit, independent living funds, imminent introduction of PIP, care services provided by local authorities and tax credits. No wonder Lady Grey-Thompson, speaking to the Guardian in February, said: “I worry that it is going to become the way it was when I was young where you just didn’t see disabled people on the street because they were locked away.”

In its recent report ‘Destination Unknown’, the charity Scope demands that the Government look at the cumulative effect of cuts to multiple benefits and social care rather than assessing the impact of each cut in isolation. Without doing so Scope believes that “it is becoming increasingly difficult for disabled people to participate in everyday family and civic life”.

So I bet the delay is because the Government has no idea how to reconcile inclusion of disabled people in society with its raft of cuts that is making that goal more and more impossible. So lets see what Autumn brings, my bet will be another announcement that the strategy is delayed once again. The Government may be happy to implement the harshest of cuts on the most vulnerable of society, but this Government is focused on good PR and it doesn't have the guts to openly admit that disabled people are no longer of interest or importance to it.

Monday, 14 May 2012

An open letter to the Telegraph: get your DLA facts straight

Dear Daily Telegraph,

You had the scoop of the decade with MPs expenses. You are clearly a paper that employs excellent journalists with great research skills. It is a shame these skills weren't utilised when you interviewed Ian Duncan Smith yesterday about the changes to DLA.

Here are the basic mistakes in your article;
1. The subheader says IDS is going ahead with changes to DLA to "rid the system of abuse and fraud". The Government's own figures show DLA fraud is 0.5% for 2010/11. To start the article as you did just cements the idea in the mind of the public that all disabled people are scroungers and consequently kindles negative attitudes towards disabled people.

2. IDS says the number of claimants have risen by 30%. This isn't true. According to IDS's own department, the claimant case has risen by 16% amongst working-age claimants, to whom these changes will only apply, once population growth has been taken into account.

3. "The rigorous new process being introduced by Mr Duncan Smith could lead to those without limbs, including former soldiers, having their payments reduced as their everyday mobility is not undermined by their prosthetic limbs". If you read the Government's draft qualifying criteria for Personal Independence Payments (that is replacing DLA) you'd have realised this statement is disingenous. It clearly says that even if your everyday mobility is severely limited through amputation, under the new system you'll receive minimal support to help with this. Case study 7 says "Andy is 50. His left leg was crushed and had to be amputated above the knee and his right leg was also injured.The scar on his left stump has not healed very well so he has difficulties with his prosthesis and his right leg is weak. He finds it very tiring if he walks more than 40-50m so he often uses a wheelchair if he is going outdoors. Mobility activities = 10 (standard rate Mobility component)". This means that the Government recognises that Andy cannot walk more than 50metres, that, to use IDS's terminology, his 'everyday mobility' is undermined but will only award him 10 points. This means he will no longer be able to access the motobility scheme which allows him to rent a car to give him the freedom that his body no longer allows him.

4."In the assessment, lots of people weren’t actually seen. They didn’t get a health check or anything like that". To get DLA you are medically assessed by the doctors and hospital workers that see you regularly. They need to provide supporting evidence to the DWP that your disability or illness is as you have described it. The DWP regularly contacts doctors who have provided supporting evidence for extra information before it makes a decision. This is why it is actually very hard to be awarded DLA and why the fraud rate is so low.

5."Something like 70 per cent had lifetime awards, (which) meant that once they got it you never looked at them again". This 70 per cent figure may be true and it is very high, but to suggest that some people should not receive lifetime awards shouldn't automatically mean that no-one receives lifetime awards. Many claimants have degenerative incurable illnesses such as Parkinson's or, like me, Cystic fibrosis, or are permanently paralysed. We can't get better, so if we are found to need help this year then the same will be true in four years time. It is a waste of taxpayer's money to reassess all claimants every few years.

6. You quote IDS as saying "Tony Blair’s government tried to attack DLA, just to restrict it. We’re not doing that". Actually IDS is. The Government declared in its Budget 2010 policy costings document that it intends to save 20% from its DLA budget by changing the way it is allocated - this is the very definition of restricting DLA.

There are other things I do not agree with with this article, but as they are matters of tone not fact you have a right to editorial control over these issues. I appreciate that the Telegraph is right-leaning and therefore broadly supportive of the current Government, but by swallowing every fact uttered by IDS without question, this piece reads as a poor advertorial for the Government's cuts, and not as a strong, piece of quality journalism.

Yours sincerely,

Sharon

p.s. All links go to DWP or Government documents freely available on the web, so you could have easily found such reputable sources yourself.

Wednesday, 9 May 2012

NHS could be the real problem for the coalition come election time

After last week’s wake-up call at the local elections, the Coalition is under pressure to re-examine how its policies reflect voters’ expectations. While there is much debate about the merits of Lord reform, gay marriage, austerity targets and growth policies, the two parties would do well to turn their attention to recent passing of the Health and Social Care bill.

Yesterday’s decision by the Government to veto the information commissioner’s legal demand to publish the risk register reminds us all what a controversial bill this truly was. The Government is still not keen to reveal to the public the extremities of the risk assessment, although an early version of the register, leaked in March, suggests that the worst case scenario of these reforms would be that “the Bill proceeds, without assurance that the whole system is affordable." The document continues: "There is a risk that costs of the future system cannot be controlled."

No wonder the bill received such widespread criticism in the run-up to it becoming law.  In February this year, eight significant health organisations fully opposed the bill, two opposed it in its current form and three were neutral. On top of that a YouGov survey showed the 65% of NHS staff wanted the bill withdrawn in its entirety.

I repeat these statistics as it shows the uphill battle the Government has to secure good outcomes from such a fiercely unpopular policy.

Since the bill became law there has been on-the-ground confusion on how best to implement its policy’s, a situation not helped by aggressive private companies there were waiting in the wings ready to take advantage of this initial knowledge vacumn. Virgin now controls 18 NHS contracts across 15 counties, and Labour back-bencher Dr Éoin Clarke estimates that £2 billion worth of NHS contracts have now been given to private companies.

Despite this plethora of contracts there is no evidence that such outsourcing of NHS contracts will deliver better services, increased choice or long-term control of costs. Indeed, the first NHS hospital to be completely privately run, Hinchingbrooke in Cambridgeshire, has recently caused a furore by announcing it intends to make a profit of £60 million in the next decade despite concerns that to do so would mean making 'eyewatering cuts'. On top of this there are ludicrous stories of physiotherapists who aren’t allowed to touch their patients following a new contract agreed by Principia clinical commissioning group (replacing the local Primacy Care Trust) in Rushcliffe, Nottinghamshire.

If a patient is unhappy with the care they are offered they can complain to Healthwatch, but they’d have to wait five months as, despite the fact that the bill is already on the statute books, it doesn’t launch until October this year. Once this organisation does finally get round to opening, it can then pass on complaints to the Care Quality Commission (CQC) which is now responsible for ensuring that private health providers are honouring the quality expected of them. This is the same CQC that has been overseeing private social care providers since 2009 and has twice been humiliated by BBC Panorama revelation's of abuse at care homes that the CQC had already inspected multiple times and declared acceptable. Despite clearly struggling in its current role, the Government expects the CQC to more than double its workload with 30% less staff.  The public may accept private providers profiting from NHS work, but in exchange it will expect the service it receives to be better than what is currently on offer and it is clear that the systems in place to manage this are already found wanting before they get off the starting block.

It isn’t even clear that in the current rush to implement these reforms the basic principles of free market capitalism are honoured, a principle that is the bedrock behind the spending decentralisation of this Tory-led Government. Despite health secretary Lansley’s much vaunted initiative of giving GPs the budget and power to buy services for its patients, it is alleged one local commissioning group in West Sussex weren’t told about a new contract award to Virgin healthcare until after it was signed off.  The commissioning board were therefore not able to consider the merit of the bid in comparison to other interested parties – a clear failure of the health bill’s objective of tendering-out NHS work to help achieve better value for money for the taxpayer.

After such a turbulent month the Government most probably couldn’t bear the horrendous headlines that would result if it revealed what risks it is truly taking with our beloved NHS. But whether made public or not, those risks outlined by the risk register still remain. No doubt the Government is hedging its bets that the new Health Bill would have bedded in by the time an election is called in 2015, and any initial concerns by the public would have been proved false. Three years is also enough time for the NHS as we know it to have unravelled, for charges for non-urgent surgery or treatment to be mooted, for waiting lists to grow, for private companies to make large profits while limiting the contact patients have with doctors. And the first few months of policy implementation don't embue one with confidence that the NHS is in safe hands.

So Cameron and Clegg be warned: the battle to push the health bill through parliament could prove miniscule compared to the battle on voters’ doorsteps in 2015 to convince them that you can be trusted with the NHS.

Wednesday, 28 March 2012

My predictions for the future disintegration of the NHS

Yesterday the health and social care bill was made law. So what are my predictions for the future of our beloved NHS? 
  • In the short-term there will be a vacumn of authority as the old system devolves power to GPs who are learning on the job. I predict there will be a flurry of contracts awarded to private companies to take control of local commissioning and health services as GPs struggle with the enormity of the challenge imposed upon them
  • In the medium-term integration between departments and hospitals will begin to splinter as hospitals concentrate on pulling punters into their doors in order to 'win' funding from GPs. (For example from my own experience Chelsea & Westminster hospital send their doctors to Brompton hospital to enable joint consultation for CF patients who also have liver disease. I can imagine such arrangements ending due to funding complications.)  
Waiting lists will rise as services try to stick to budgets by rationing care and maximising the number of private patients they treat. The bill allows up to 49% of work at NHS hospitals to be given over to private patients.
More and more obese people and smokers will find themselves denied services as GPs find any excuse to limit care in order to meet spiralling costs. 
National scandals will arise in which private health companies are accussed of patient neglect and care as they cut services in order to make a profit. This has already happened under Bupa.  
  • In the longer-term, we'll all get used to paying for some NHS services. I can easily imagine paying for evening and weekend doctors appointments as it'll be billed that you are buying the convenience of the time, not the service. 
It'll become routine to take private healthcare if you can afford it.
  • In the very long-term the NHS will become a safety net only for those who have no private healthcare, and people will expect only the most basic care for it. 
As such the life expectancy gap between the rich and poor will continue to widen.
The health and social care bill is the worst thing this Government has done while in power, and Cameron and Clegg will be hated for it by future generations far more than Thatcher ever was for her deindustrialisation drive and war on the miners.

Tuesday, 27 March 2012

Today the NHS is dying. Cameron & Clegg will never be forgiven.

So let's mark this date in our calendars and tell our grandchildren. The NHS - that wonderful institution created after a war in which every family came to experience first-hand what it was to suffer and to lose loved ones -  is officially dying. Today, the Health and Social care bill became law.

  • It allows private providers to cherry pick what services it provides leaving NHS to pick up the problem patients which don't present an easy profit (the Lib Dems have claimed they have amended the bill to prevent this happening but their amendment only demands that providers are transparent when they do cherry pick).
  • It forces hospitals to compete against each other for funding meaning that they are at threat of unplanned closure if they don't get enough patients. It also promotes competition rather than integration of care which is what is needed to help better manage the prevention of long-term conditions such as diabetes and liver disease, two illnesses that are rising exponentially and are a massive drain on NHS resources.
  • It allows up to 49% of work at NHS hospitals to be given over to private patients effectively doubling the waiting list for those people who can't afford private health insurance.
  • The risk register, that the Government refused to release despite repeated demands to do so from the Information Commission, was leaked yesterday. It is thought to be an early draft but it clearly warns that the Bill could make the NHS unaffordable: "[A risk that ] design work proceeds without the confirmation of cost envelopes for each organisation which means that the future system design is signed off, and the Bill proceeds, without assurance that the whole system is affordable. One example of area where system could be more costly is if GP Consortia makes use of private sector organisations/staff which adds costs to the overall system". The document continues:: "[A risk that] Future efficiencies cannot be managed and driven through the system effectively, because there is no organisation to plan and manage holistic efficiency programmes. So there is a risk that costs of the future system cannot be controlled."
So what are my predictions?  
  • In the short-term there will be a vacumn of authority as the old system devolves power to GPs who are learning on the job. I predict there will be a flurry of contracts awarded to private companies to take control of local commissioning and health services as GPs struggle with the enormity of the challenge imposed upon them
  • In the medium-term integration between departments and hospitals will begin to splinter as hospitals concentrate on pulling punters into their doors in order to 'win' funding from GPs. (For example from my own experience Chelsea & Westminster hospital send their doctors to Brompton hospital to enable joint consultation for CF patients who also have liver disease. I can imagine such arrangements ending due to funding complications.)  
Waiting lists will rise as services try to stick to budgets by rationing care
More and more obese people and smokers will find themselves denied services as GPs find any excuse to limit care in order to meet spiralling costs. 
    National scandals will arise in which private health companies are accussed of patient neglect and care as they cut services in order to make a profit. This has already happened under Bupa.  
    • In the longer-term, we'll all get used to paying for some NHS services. I can easily imagine paying for evening and weekend doctors appointments as it'll be billed that you are buying the convenience of the time, not the service. 
    It'll become routine to take private healthcare if you can afford it.
      • In the very long-term the NHS will become a safety net only for those who have no private healthcare, and people will expect only the most basic care for it. 
      As such the life expectancy gap between the rich and poor will continue to widen.
        So as I say, mark this date in your diary. The health and social care bill is the worst thing this Government has done while in power, and Cameron and Clegg will be hated for it by future generations far more than Thatcher ever was for her deindustrialisation drive and war on the miners.

        Thursday, 22 March 2012

        Budget 2012: the disabled marginalised yet again

        Yesterday's budget contained a kick in the teeth for disabled people, quickly followed by a punch in the face.

        The Chancellor's retreat on child benefit, moving the threshold for ineligibility from those earning over £43,000 to those earning over £60,000, was a bare-faced example of the Government looking after its own voters. When the planned benefit cut was announced last year there were howls of outrage amongst higher rate earners, and the Tories, mindful an election has to be fought in perhaps two years time, decided to try and save their own skins.

        How is this relevant to disabled people?

        When the recent Welfare reform Bill passed through the House of Lords, three defeats were enacted on the Government as the Lords chose to make changes that they believed would safe-guard some of the most sick and disabled in the country. One of those changes was to extend the length of time that people on contributory-based Employment Support Allowance could claim the benefit. The Government proposed that those people place in the Working Capability Group of ESA (so claimants who are too ill to work but should be able to in the future) could only claim the benefit for a year. The Lords voted to extend this to two years to ensure that people had enough time to get better before being forced into work. Macmillan cancer support for example argued that annually 7.000 cancer patients, routinely placed in the Working group of ESA, take longer than 12 months to recover.

        Although the Lords followed due democratic process to enact these changes, they have not come into force. The Government used 'financial privilege' to block these amendments. In short, MPs cried "Sorry, no money!" and did so in a way that has seen no precedent.

        But suddenly come budget day, the Government discovered a stash of cash to save the child benefit of higher rate tax-payers, those who are doing ok in life, and yet still no money to extend ESA for those who are too sick to work through no fault of their own. More worryingly for democracy, the Government places greater value on the opinion of its voters then on the democratic process of a Bill being passed into law.

        The second fear hidden in the budget was Osborne's casual mention that Ian Duncan Smith would have to find a further £10 billion of welfare cuts on top of the £18 billion already slashed from these bills. The biggest slice of welfare is spent on old age - with today's vicious headlines about a granny tax I can't see the Government making any further cuts to pensioners. Child benefit cuts now seem completely off the table, a decision that Ian Duncan Smith may come to resent Osborne for as he frantically tries to cut £10 billion.

        So where can more cuts be found? Housing benefit perhaps, childcare credits even, but a clear forerunner would be disability benefits. Disability Living Allowance is already scheduled to be scrapped next year, and replaced by Personal Independence Payments (PIP). In the Government's last spending review it arbitrarily decided to cut recipients of PIP by 20%, before it had even decided the criteria for eligibility or assessed the needs of a single disabled person.

        What's the betting that in the next spending review the Government decides to save 25% or even 30% from the PIP bill? I for one am very worried.

        Wednesday, 21 March 2012

        What practical changes to Atos's WCA would you recommend to the Government?

        The 'Responsible Reform' Spartacus report revealed the power of social media in helping to raise awareness to the cuts faced by disabled people in the UK. It got the House of Lords to listen to disabled people. If it wasn't for a the Government utilising the Commons 'financial privilege' in a way that has seen no precedent, significant changes would have been made to the Welfare Bill that would have protected disabled people from some of its worst 'reforms'.

        So thinking about this success, and following on from the brilliant article written by Amelia Gentleman in the Guardian earlier this week, I thought it would be great to capture people's experiences of Atos's Working Capability Assessment (WCA) to pull together recommendations for the Government to help make the process fairer.

        As much as many people reading this will say the WCA shouldn't exist, my main focus is to work within the system that has been imposed on us (and which no political party has recommended repealing) to think of practical changes that the Government could implement immediately and at no cost. Listed below are my initial thoughts. Please do comment and add your thoughts too.

        1. DWP should give doctors' reports equal weight as Atos's WCA medical test
        Although Atos conduct the 'independent' medical test it is the DWP who have the final decision about who does and doesn't receive ESA. It is widely felt amongst the disabled community that in reality the DWP are just rubber stamping the decision made by Atos's medical test, at it is the company's system of awarding points to a claimant's illness that decides if someone reaches the threshold of eligibility. A simple change would be to give equal weight to the reports given to the DWP by the claimant's own doctors and to the report provided by Atos. Where there is a clear discrepancy in the perceived ability of a claimant the DWP could step in early to demand more informationn from both parties, hopefully reducing the number of mistakes made and the huge cost to the Government of managing appeals against DWP's ESA decisions.

        2. Stop the continual cycle of re-testing
        One of the shocking problems within the ESA system, is that once a claimant has waited up to nine months to have his or her case heard at the court of appeal and finally been awarded ESA, they can be recalled for another medical within months of the appeal being heard. This second medical then strips the claimant of ESA forcing them back into the stressful and lengthy appeal process. This makes no sense to either the claimant who is struggling to regain their health or to the tax payer which is paying £50 million a year for this appeals merry-go-round. At each appeal hearing, each claimant should be given a date before which they cannot be called back for another medical and the DWP must be made to honour this date. I suggest a year before retests but opinions are welcome on this.

        3. Impose financial penalties on Atos for incorrect decisions
        A Commons select committee report last year highlighted that Atos may be driven by a profit motive to, in their words, "get the assessments done, but not necessarily to get the assessments right". The Government should treat Atos like any other private contractor and impose financial penalties for incorrect decisions. Clearly a margin of error may be acceptable but decisions in which a claimant has been awarded 0 points by Atos to then be awarded 15 points on appeal cannot be justified. It isn't in the taxpayers interest to fund an appeal process worth £50 million a year while letting Atos retain all of its £100 million annual fee.


        Please do let me know what you think - it would be great to work together as a social media community to create key recommendations from those who have been through the WCA process to try and make a difference to those who have to endure it in the future.